DefinePK hosts the largest index of Pakistani journals, research articles, news headlines, and videos. It also offers chapter-level book search.
Title: Addressing the Decline in Clinical Skills: A Call for Comprehensive Educational Reform
Authors: Muhammad Noor Wazir
Journal: Journal of Gandhara Medical and Dental Sciences (JGMDS)
Publisher: Gandhara University, Peshawar
Country: Pakistan
Year: 2024
Volume: 11
Issue: 3
Language: English
Despite technological advances, clinical skills are the foundation of medical practice. Taking a comprehensive clinical history, performing physical examinations, and communicating effectively are crucial for high-quality patient care. Medical students need to focus on developing strong clinical skills to ensure they are well-prepared for their careers and adapt to the evolving field of medicine through continual practice and refinement.1 The medical community is worried about declining essential clinical skills among undergraduate medical students.2,3 This editorial aims to analyze the reasons for the decline and suggest evidence-based methods to address the situation. 05885.0258063. The declining standards of clinical skills among medical students can be attributed to the widespread adoption of technology-based learning, which has the potential to diminish the importance of traditional hands-on bedside teaching.4 Technology should enhance, not replace, practical clinical experiences. Practical training improves the clinical abilities, expertise, and self-assurance of medical students.5 Moreover, the growing magnitude and expansion of medical curricula provide difficulties in the development of educational programs without ample time for bedside practical teaching.6,7 There is frequently an excessive focus on remembering facts rather than on cultivating clinical reasoning abilities.8 The reduced patient interaction during medical school, due to increased reliance on simulations and less time in clinical rotations and bedside teaching, hampers the development of clinical skills.9 External factors such as limited time and extensive paperwork may affect the quality of patient encounters. Efficient communication is crucial for building good relationships with patients, obtaining accurate medical histories, and ensuring patient understanding and adherence to treatment.9 Insufficient training in communication skills can result in less-than-ideal interactions between patients and healthcare providers and can also contribute to errors in diagnosis and medical treatment.10
The provision of trained faculty for teaching medical students is an issue worldwide. Insufficient supervision and feedback during clinical rotations hinder the development of essential clinical skills.11 Larger student cohorts reduce the opportunities for individual students to practice and receive personalized instruction in clinical skills.12 Medical education often prioritizes theoretical testing over practical examinations and undervalues communication skills training. Variability in clinical experiences at different medical schools can lead to inconsistencies in skill acquisition. The scarcity of skilled clinicians as role models impacts students’ learning. Economic constraints and modern healthcare pressures limit opportunities for thorough patient interactions and clinical training.13
THE WAY FORWARD
Educational institutions should prioritize hands-on clinical experiences throughout the curriculum to improve students’ diagnostic and communication abilities. These experiences should include simulation-based learning, standardized patients, and longitudinal clerkships. Faculty members need support and resources for effective clinical mentorship and development. Reflective practice should be integrated into the curriculum to enhance self-awareness and critical thinking. Open communication and mentorship programs between students and faculty can strengthen medical training and promote continual learning.
To address declining clinical proficiency among medical students, institutions can adopt evidence-based approaches including curriculum changes, faculty training, promoting reflective thinking, collaboration among healthcare professionals, and fostering a culture of ongoing learning. Regulatory bodies should ensure adequate time for bedside teaching and appropriate assessment weightage.
To analyze the reasons for the decline in essential clinical skills among undergraduate medical students and suggest evidence-based methods to address this situation.
This is an editorial that analyzes the issue of declining clinical skills. It draws upon existing literature and expert opinion to identify contributing factors and propose solutions.
graph TD;
A["Identify Decline in Clinical Skills"] --> B["Analyze Causes"];
B --> C["Propose Evidence-Based Solutions"];
C --> D["Call for Comprehensive Educational Reform"];
D --> E["Emphasize Role of Institutions and Regulatory Bodies"];
The editorial argues that while technology has its place, it should augment rather than replace traditional hands-on bedside teaching. It emphasizes the need for a curriculum that prioritizes practical clinical experiences, effective mentorship, reflective practice, and open communication. Regulatory bodies are called upon to ensure sufficient time for bedside teaching and appropriate assessment weightage.
The decline in clinical skills is attributed to the over-reliance on technology, expansion of medical curricula, reduced patient interaction, insufficient training in communication, inadequate faculty supervision, large student cohorts, prioritization of theoretical over practical assessment, variability in clinical experiences, scarcity of skilled role models, and economic/healthcare pressures.
Comprehensive educational reform is necessary to address the decline in clinical skills. This reform should involve curriculum changes, faculty training, promoting reflective thinking, collaboration, and fostering a culture of continuous learning, with regulatory oversight to ensure adequate practical training and assessment.
1. Publication Year: The editorial is published in 2024. (Confirmed by citation)
2. Journal Name: The editorial is published in the Journal of Gandhara Medical and Dental Sciences (J Gandhara Med Dent Sci). (Confirmed by citation)
3. DOI: The editorial provides a DOI: https://doi.org/10.37762/jgmds.11-3. (Confirmed by citation)
Loading PDF...
Loading Statistics...