DefinePK hosts the largest index of Pakistani journals, research articles, news headlines, and videos. It also offers chapter-level book search.
Title: The Application of Choice Experiment Methodology to the Freshwater Ecosystem Services: A Review
Authors: Ronaq Zaman, Shahid Ali
Journal: International Journal of Business and Economic Affairs (IJBEA)
Publisher: Global Illuminators
Country: Pakistan
Year: 2023
Volume: 8
Issue: 3
Language: English
DOI: 10.24088/IJBEA-2023-830016
Keywords: Ecosystem servicesEconomic evaluationStated preferencesChoice setsWater-ecosystems
Evaluating ecosystem services is difficult due to the complexity of ecosystem processes and the ambiguity around the size and timing of any threshold impact associated with an ecological disturbance. The finest methods for measuring values in the context of ecological non-linearity among economic valuation methodologies are said to be stated preference (S.P) methods. This is because the stated preference approach does not use revealed preference (R.P) techniques to deduce preferences from people’s behavior in actual market settings. Thus, it seems acceptable to construct the valuation approach of interest to value several hypothetical ecological situations to demonstrate the sensitivity of the created values to each potential outcome. Due to its design specifications, which call for the creation of various choice sets with a specific number of distinct scenarios (i.e., alternatives) to be presented to respondents so they may choose their most preferred one from each option set, the choice experiment could play a significant role in this regard.
To conduct a comprehensive review of previous studies that employed choice experiment methodology for water resource conservation and management, and to critically analyze the literature on environmental resources (specifically water resources) to better understand public perception.
This paper is a review of existing literature. It analyzes studies that have used the choice experiment methodology to evaluate public preferences and willingness to pay for freshwater ecosystem services. The review categorizes studies by publication year (2000-2010, 2011-2020, 2021-present) and discusses their findings and applications.
graph TD
A["Literature Review"] --> B["Analysis of Choice Experiment Studies"];
B --> C["Identification of Key Findings and Trends"];
C --> D["Synthesis of Methodological Strengths and Limitations"];
D --> E["Formulation of Conclusions and Recommendations"];
E --> F["Report Generation"];
The complexity of valuing ecosystem services, particularly freshwater resources, necessitates robust valuation methodologies. The choice experiment method, a stated preference technique, is well-suited for this purpose as it can capture both use and non-use values, which are crucial for public goods like environmental resources. The review highlights the consistent application of CE across different geographical regions and for diverse water-related issues, demonstrating its versatility and effectiveness in informing policy and management decisions. The discussion also touches upon the importance of considering spatial variability and individual preferences in valuation studies.
The choice experiment (CE) methodology is a suitable and well-supported approach for eliciting public preferences and willingness to pay (WTP) for improving freshwater ecosystem services. CE offers advantages over other stated preference methods, such as the contingent valuation method (CVM), by allowing for the estimation of implicit prices for specific attributes and the valuation of changes beyond existing levels. Numerous studies have successfully used CE to assess WTP for various aspects of water quality, biodiversity, and river basin management.
The choice experiment methodology is a powerful tool for evaluating freshwater ecosystem services and informing conservation and management strategies. Its ability to elicit detailed preferences and willingness to pay for specific environmental attributes makes it invaluable for policymakers. Continued research and application of CE are recommended to enhance our understanding of public perception and to guide effective water resource management.
* The paper states that the Millennium Ecosystem Assessment (MEA) was first conducted in 2003 and 2005. This is correct.
* The paper mentions that the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD), Millennium Development Goals (MDG), and Inter-government Science-Policy Platform (ISPP) connect biodiversity conservation to ecosystem services. This is accurate.
* The paper cites a study by Loomis et al. (2000) which found that households were willing to pay $21 per month or $252 yearly for an improvement in ecosystem services. This is a reported finding from the cited study.
Loading PDF...
Loading Statistics...