DefinePK hosts the largest index of Pakistani journals, research articles, news headlines, and videos. It also offers chapter-level book search.
Title: روایات شق صدر پر سرسید احمد خان کے بیانیہ کا ناقدانہ جائزہ:
Authors: Muhammad Amir Farooq, Muhammad Naseer
Journal: Ulum al-Sunnah
| Category | From | To |
|---|---|---|
| Y | 2024-10-01 | 2025-12-31 |
Publisher: Islamia University, Bahawalpur
Country: Pakistan
Year: 2024
Volume: 2
Issue: 2
Language: Urdu
Keywords: HadithSir Syed Ahmad KhanRationalismShaq-e-Sadr
The current era is one of the advancements of rational sciences, where everything is measured and weighed on the scales of Rationality, and it is considered the definitive standard for determining right and wrong. However, revelation (Wahi) holds a status above Rationality. It is not necessary for all information provided by revelation to align with rationality. In the past, influenced by the prominence of rational sciences, some individuals actively attempted to align revelation with the framework of rationality. Among these individuals, one prominent figure in the recent past was Sir Syed Ahmed Khan, who worked on this subject. One of the topics he addressed was the miracle of Shaqq-e-Sadr (purifying Prophet Muhammad's heart). To bring this miracle into the domain of rationality, Sir Syed adopted two approaches in his discourse: 1. He denied the actual occurrence of the event and attempted to prove it as a dream. 2. He questioned the authenticity of the Ahadees(About Sahqq e Sadar) that support the event as a real occurrence in a state of wakefulness. In the present age of rationalism, it is essential to preserve the Real status of revelation, so This article critically examines both claims made by Sir Syed Ahmed Khan
To critically examine Sir Syed Ahmad Khan's two approaches in rationalizing the miracle of Shaqq-e-Sadr (purifying Prophet Muhammad's heart): denying its actual occurrence and questioning the authenticity of ahadees supporting it as a real event in a state of wakefulness.
Critical review of Sir Syed Ahmad Khan's discourse on the miracle of Shaqq-e-Sadr, analyzing his arguments for rationalizing the event.
graph TD;
A["Identify Sir Syed Ahmad Khan's discourse on Shaqq-e-Sadr"] --> B["Analyze his two approaches: dream interpretation and ahadees authenticity questioning"];
B --> C["Critically evaluate these approaches"];
C --> D["Formulate conclusions on preserving the status of revelation"];
The paper discusses the tension between rationalism and revelation in the contemporary era, highlighting Sir Syed Ahmad Khan's efforts to reconcile them by reinterpreting religious miracles. It argues for the preservation of the real status of revelation in the face of rationalistic interpretations.
Sir Syed Ahmad Khan attempted to rationalize the miracle of Shaqq-e-Sadr by either denying its literal occurrence and interpreting it as a dream, or by questioning the authenticity of the ahadees that describe it as a real event during wakefulness.
The article concludes by critically examining Sir Syed Ahmad Khan's rationalistic interpretations of the Shaqq-e-Sadr miracle, emphasizing the importance of maintaining the integrity of revelation.
1. Claim: Sir Syed Ahmad Khan adopted two approaches to rationalize the miracle of Shaqq-e-Sadr.
Confirmation: The text explicitly states these two approaches: denying the actual occurrence and interpreting it as a dream, and questioning the authenticity of ahadees supporting it as a real occurrence in wakefulness.
2. Claim: The article is published in Ulm al-Sunnah, Volume 02 No. 02 (July-December 2024).
Confirmation: This information is present at the beginning of the provided text.
3. Claim: The ISSN numbers are 2959-2224 (Online) and 2959-2216 (Print).
Confirmation: These ISSN numbers are listed at the beginning of the provided text.
Loading PDF...
Loading Statistics...