DefinePK

Research Objective

To analyze Al-Ghazali's theory of `illah and maqasid al-shari`ah in detail to determine the validity of Imran Ahsan Nyazee's claims that Al-Shafi` had no concept of qiyas al `illah and that his book al-Rislah offers no example of it.

Methodology

Textual analysis of Al-Ghazali's theories on `illah and maqasid al-shari`ah, and a critical examination of Imran Ahsan Nyazee's views on Al-Shafi`'s concept of qiyas.

Methodology Flowchart

                        graph TD
    A[Analyze Al-Ghazali's Theory of `Illah and Maqasid al Shari`ah] --> B[Critically Examine Nyazee's Views on Al-Shafi`'s Qiyas];
    B --> C[Determine Validity of Nyazee's Claims];
    C --> D[Elaborate on Al-Ghazali's Theoretical Foundations];
    D --> E[Present Findings and Conclusions];                    

Discussion

The article elaborates on Al-Ghazali's theory of `illah and maqasid al-shari`ah, aiming to refute Nyazee's assertion that Al-Shafi` lacked the concept of qiyas al `illah. It highlights the foundational role of Al-Ghazali's work in Islamic jurisprudence.

Key Findings

Imran Ahsan Nyazee's categorization of Al-Shafi`'s views on qiyas with critics of qiyas is challenged. The article argues that Al-Ghazali's theories provide theoretical underpinnings for maqasid al-shari`ah that are often overlooked.

Conclusion

The article aims to provide a detailed explanation of Al-Ghazali's theories to reassess Nyazee's claims about Al-Shafi`'s understanding of qiyas al `illah. It emphasizes the significance of Al-Ghazali's contributions to the concept of maqasid al-shari`ah.

Fact Check

1. Claim: Imran Ahsan Nyazee categorized Al-Shafi`'s views on qiyas with the likes of Dawood al Zhir.
Confirmation: The text states this as Nyazee's categorization.
2. Claim: Al-Shafi`'s book is titled "al Rislah."
Confirmation: The text refers to "his book al Rislah."
3. Claim: The article aims to determine the validity of Nyazee's claims.
Confirmation: This is explicitly stated as the article's objective.

Mind Map